Soapbox Engage Blog

TL;DR: Winning donation appeals are vital for attracting supporters and securing funds. To raise more for your cause, it's essential that you optimize your outreach at every touchpoint. Strong subject lines, workplace giving programs, engaging stories, and more can go a long way toward increasing fundraising revenue.

Compelling donation appeals are the lifeblood of impactful nonprofit fundraising. Crafting effective asks can not only enhance your organization's ability to attract and retain donors but ultimately increase your funding and impact overall.

So, how can you supercharge your outreach efforts to raise more for your cause? Among the various strategies to boost your appeals, several stand out as particularly fruitful. In this guide, we'll walk through the following tips to help you maximize your fundraising with strong appeals:

1. Start with a strong subject line.
2. Mention workplace giving opportunities.
3. Employ engaging storytelling strategies.
4. Personalize appeal messaging when possible.
5. Supply recommended donation amounts.
6. Segment outreach by preferred appeal channel.
7. Use eye-catching visuals and consistent branding.

Ready to find out how your team can bring its engagement to the next level? Let's dive in!

1. Start with a strong subject line.

Many organizations send donation appeals via email. When doing so, your subject line is the earliest impression your outreach makes on its recipient, so it's crucial to grab your readers' attention immediately. In fact, the subject is often the deciding factor as to whether to open the appeal in the first place!

Check out the following tips and tricks as you begin crafting your communications:

Establish a sense of urgency to drive immediate action.

• Ex: "With 24 hours left to reach our goal, will you make a donation to the cause?"

Foster a personal connection with the recipient.

• Ex: "Your generous support makes our mission possible, Jane. Help us bring our efforts to the next level."

Mention matching gifts to pique curiosity and reiterate impact.

• Ex: "Make a greater impact on our cause by giving and requesting a match!"

2. Mention workplace giving opportunities.

One of the best ways to inspire donor support is to promote relevant workplace giving opportunities. Many companies offer employee-led philanthropy programs as a way to engage their staff and support nonprofit causes. Two key programs to keep in mind:

• Payroll deductions: This type of initiative allows employees to donate to nonprofits directly from their salaries on a recurring basis. These automatic deductions are budget-friendly and ensure a steady, predictable income stream for your organization.
• Matching gifts: Employers often match donations made by employees to eligible nonprofits. When donors know their gifts can be multiplied, they're much more likely to give. Data reports that mentioning matching opportunities increases average appeal response rates by 71% and average donation amounts by 51%.

However, many eligible donors remain unaware of these opportunities, resulting in billions of dollars in workplace gifts going unclaimed each year. And one of the best places to begin raising awareness of these programs is directly within your donation appeals.

3. Employ engaging storytelling strategies.

When it comes to fundraising, a story can be a powerful tool for engaging and connecting with donors. Within your appeals, you'll want to use smart storytelling strategies to illustrate the impact of donations, not to mention the added benefit of matching gifts.

For example, you might share a story about a beneficiary whose life was changed thanks to a generous gift and/or donation match: "Bert's journey out of homelessness was made possible not just by your generous donation, but by a matching gift from your employer, ultimately doubling the resources available to support him."

4. Personalize appeal messaging when possible.

Personalization can significantly increase the effectiveness of your donation requests. It means each recipient knows the message was crafted just for them, rather than taking a broader "one-size-fits-all" approach. The Soapbox Engage Donations app allows you to craft personalized appeals, donor thank-yous, confirmation pages, and email receipts.

Addressing donors by name and referencing their past contributions shows that you value their support on a personal level. When mentioning matching gifts, you can take personalization a step further by including details about their employer. Here's an example: "Jane, did you know that Microsoft matches donations to nonprofits like ours? Your support could go twice as far for our mission!"

If you don't know where an individual works, consider a data append service to help fill in the gaps.

5. Supply recommended donation amounts.

Studies show that, when asking supporters for donations, it's a good idea to provide suggested giving amounts. Not only can this simplify the donor's experience by removing a point of friction (answering the question of "what is the right amount to give?"), but it also encourages giving in larger amounts.

For the best results, customize your recommended gift sizes based on the recipient and their estimated ability to give. It's also a good idea to take matching gift program requirements into account. For example, many companies implement a minimum threshold of $25. To capture matching gift revenue, align your lowest gift tiers with standard corporate minimums.

6. Segment outreach by preferred appeal channel.

There are many ways your organization can reach its donors, from individual outreach to mass communications. Your team may have its highest-performing channels, but you'll want to consider your recipients' preferences as you plan your engagements as well.

Different donors may prefer to be reached through different media, such as email, direct mail, social media, and text messages. For example, you might have a mailing address on file for a particular donor, but if the individual doesn't regularly check their mailbox, they're not likely to receive your direct mail appeal in a timely manner.

Segmenting outreach based on these favored channels can go a long way toward increasing engagement.

7. Use eye-catching visuals and consistent branding.

Well-chosen visual elements can significantly enhance the appeal of your donation requests. We recommend employing eye-catching visuals to engage your audience, illustrate the impact of donations on your mission, and demonstrate the tangible value of matching gifts.

Regardless of the content you share, you'll want to ensure that your imagery and overall branding remain steady across all communications. Consistent color schemes, fonts, and graphic styles can reinforce your organization's identity and make your appeals more impactful. The Soapbox Engage Donations app offers extensive customization and brand consistency on any device.

---

Boosting the overall effectiveness of your nonprofit's donation appeals can go a long way. By implementing these recommended strategies, your team can encourage more donations and facilitate greater engagement from your supporters.

If you're ready to raise more through individual giving and workplace giving, learn how the Soapbox Engage and Double the Donation integration can help scale your efforts. Good luck!